LR-101 · Module 1

New Tools, New Liabilities

3 min read

AI is not a software upgrade. It is a new category of business tool with a new category of legal exposure. Traditional contracts were drafted for deterministic systems — software that does exactly what the specification says, every time. AI does not work that way. It generates outputs based on probabilistic inference, which means the same input can produce different outputs, and nobody — not the developer, not the deployer, not the client — can guarantee what it will say next.

This matters legally because most existing contract language assumes predictable behavior. Warranty clauses promise the software will perform "as described in the documentation." Indemnification clauses allocate risk based on whose product caused the harm. Limitation of liability provisions cap exposure based on what could reasonably go wrong. AI breaks every one of these assumptions. The documentation cannot fully describe probabilistic outputs. Determining whose product "caused" an AI error is genuinely ambiguous. And what can "reasonably go wrong" with a system that generates novel content is a question no court has definitively answered.

Do This

  • Review existing contract templates for AI-specific gaps before your next engagement
  • Ask: does this warranty clause account for probabilistic outputs?
  • Flag any indemnification language that assumes deterministic software behavior
  • Treat AI engagements as a distinct contract category, not a variant of software consulting

Avoid This

  • Assume your existing MSA covers AI work — it almost certainly does not
  • Use the phrase "the software will perform as documented" for AI deliverables without qualification
  • Rely on boilerplate limitation of liability provisions written before 2023
  • Wait until a dispute forces you to discover the gap

I am not telling you this to create anxiety. I am telling you this because the organizations that address these gaps proactively will spend a fraction of what the organizations that discover them reactively will spend. A contract review costs hours. A contract dispute costs months. Read before you sign. Always.